As seen in
September 17, 2001
CITY BIZ SHOULD REBOUND AFTER SHORT-TERM
DIP
by BETH J. HARPAZ
Realtors and economists predict that
the World Trade Center attack will result in a short-term
blow to the local economy, but say that, over time, the city
will likely come out OK.
"In the short term, obviously, there's a large amount of devastation
and loss of life. It's a huge blow for New York," said Columbia
University economics Professor David Weinstein.
But Weinstein, who has studied what
happens when cities suffer catastrophes such as bombings during
wartime, said that historically, "the long-run impact is actually
quite modest.. . . In the short run, there will be a run-up
in commercial real-estate prices in the scramble to find office
space, and some businesses are going to have to move out.
But with federal help and city help, there's going to be a
rebuilding."
Mark Thompson, managing director
of Plymouth Partners, a commercial Realtor, says many companies
will relocate into space recently made vacant by the dot-com
bust. And in the long term, he predicts, there will be new
construction to help create needed offices.
But he acknowledges that some of New York's most prestigious
addresses might be less desirable from now on than an anonymous
building in downtown Brooklyn or Queens. "There may be some
issues some companies will have, [such] as being in landmark
buildings they see as potential targets," he said. "But I
don't see people fleeing New York."
Marcia Van Wagner, chief economist for the Citizen's Budget
Commission, a fiscal watchdog group, agrees that there will
likely be a short-term turndown, accelerated by the national
economic slump already in progress when Tuesday's attack on
the Twin Towers occurred.
"A year from now, if your co-op or condo is worth less, it
will probably be worth about the same that it would have been
without this," she said.
"It's not part of a structural erosion of what makes the city
competitive. That's not to say this doesn't present a fiscal
challenge. There are a lot of very big taxpayers involved
in this, and if a number of them leave the city, that's not
good for the city's fiscal base."
The attack destroyed office space for hundreds of firms and
thousands of jobs, not just in the Twin Towers but also in
surrounding buildings that are now off-limits due to structural
damage. Small businesses that provided ancillary services
to some of the firms directly hit - everything from delis
to copy shops - will experience reduced revenues from fewer
customers.
On the other hand, billions of dollars in federal aid are
in the pipeline. Insurance payments will help damaged companies
reconstitute. New jobs will be created in construction.
Largely due to the airline slowdown, tourists have largely
disappeared from normally bustling places like Times Square.
Cabs are suddenly available in neighborhoods where they used
to be impossible to find. And discount tickets are available
to Broadway shows that had been hard to see.
Van Wagner says that an immediate tourist slowdown was to
be expected, explaining, "When things like this happen, people
get superstitious about the place where the tragedy occurred."
Barbara Corcoran, who is probably the best-known high-end
Realtor in Manhattan, predicts that prices will soften in
the short term, but largely because of a wait-and-see attitude
that she expects will rule the real-estate market for the
next few months. AP

|